In California, it’s a crime to operate a vehicle while “under the influence” of alcohol or drugs or with a blood alcohol concentration (BAC) of .08% or more. Generally, California law provides sentencing guidelines for drivers convicted of a DUI. In other words, there’s a range of penalties that a judge can impose for a DUI conviction. The allowable range is determined by a variety of circumstances, including the defendant’s record and the particular facts of the current offense. Within the applicable range, judges use "mitigating" and "aggravating" factors to determine an appropriate sentence. Aggravating and mitigating circumstances can also come into play when plea bargaining with prosecutors.
This article discusses mitigating and aggravating factors and some of the circumstances that determine DUI sentencing ranges and increase DUI penalties in California.
Basically, mitigating factors are facts or circumstances that reduce a defendant’s culpability or warrant lenient sentencing. For example, if a driver was impaired because of lawfully prescribed medication, barely over the legal limit, or completes voluntary substance abuse treatment subsequent to the arrest, the judge and prosecutor may lean towards a sentence at the lower end of the allowable range. Judges and prosecutors might also look to factors like whether the defendant is gainfully employed or a good student in deciding on an appropriate sentence or plea bargain to offer.
Aggravating factors, on the other hand, are facts or circumstances that increase the severity of a criminal act or the defendant’s culpability and warrant harsher sentencing. Typical aggravating factors for DUI cases include prior convictions, high BACs, reckless driving, excessive speeding, having a suspended license, causing injuries or property damage, and having a child in the vehicle at the time of the offense. And even if the defendant has no prior DUIs, having an extensive criminal record for other offenses can dissuade a judge or prosecutor from being lenient.
Mitigating and aggravating factors (such as those described above) inform judges and prosecutors what’s warranted within the allowable range. But California law also specifies a number of circumstances that require more severe DUI penalties. Here are some of these sentencing enhancements:
In deciding how to sentence a defendant—specifically, in regard to whether to impose an enhancement or grant probation—the judge must consider a defendant’s refusal to submit to DUI chemical testing or the fact that a defendant had a BAC of .15% or more.
Most California DUIs are charged as misdemeanors. However, certain factors can elevate a DUI to a felony.
California law makes a DUI a felony if the offender caused serious injury to another person while driving under the influence. Causing the death of another person while driving under the influence can also lead to felony charges—manslaughter or second-degree murder charges.
In California, a fourth or subsequent DUI within a ten-year period is classified as a felony. For purposes of determining how many priors you have, in-state and out-of-state DUI and wet-reckless convictions are counted.
Once you have a felony DUI conviction in California, all subsequent DUI convictions are considered felony offenses.
If you’ve been arrested for a DUI, you should talk to an attorney as soon as possible. Getting sound legal advice is especially important with DUIs involving aggravating factors because the penalties are so severe. A qualified attorney can tell you how the law applies to the facts of your case and help you decide how best to proceed.